I just finished reading a post-apocalyptic YA version of Persuasion called For the Darkness Shows the Stars by Diana Peterfreund.
This book is REALLY good. It's one of my favorites of the books I've read this year (and I've read A LOT). I find the fact that it's been one of my favorites quite fascinating. I mean, it's based on Persuasion, so it's not like there are any big surprises or anything. I knew from the beginning how it was going to end and what some of the basic plot points would be. I knew that [SPOILER ALERT] the Captain Wentworth character would write the Anne Elliot character a magically romantic letter when he finally expressed his feelings for her. I think its appeal (and the appeal of other Jane Austen re-tellings) is in finding out how faithfully the author sticks to the original, how she gets us from one plot point to the next, how she modernizes the story, and, most of all, the anticipation of capturing the magic all over again.
Let's go back to that magic, specifically, the magically romantic letter from Persuasion. Is there a more perfect love letter in all of literature? Please tell me if there is. Here's the letter (because why wouldn't you want to read it):
Now that we've established that Captain Frederick Wentworth is the wordsmith all men should aspire to be, let's talk about my favorite iteration of him in film. Ciarin Hinds as Captain Wentworth in the probably-most-famous 1995 version was fine, but, at least for me, he did not fully embody the man I fell so in love with in the book. Rather, that distinction goes to Rupert Penry-Jones of the 2007 BBC version:
Where has the UK been hiding him all these years?? He is a British TV star, most famous for his role as Adam Carter on the series MI-5, which is called Spooks in the UK. All fans of Jane Austen and Persuasion should watch this movie. It's a little artsy, but it is excellent.
Disclaimer: Captain Wentworth is my second-favorite Jane Austen hero, so the opinions expressed herein may be a little biased. In case you're wondering who my favorite Jane Austen hero is, I will tell you that that particular distinction belongs to Mr. Knightley.
Hel-lo, Jonny Lee Miller. |
I love Jonny Lee Miller, but Mr. Knightly will always be played by Collin Firth in my mind. I love him. (My favorite movie version of an Austen character, though, is Mr. Knightley in "Emma," played by the handsome Jeremy Northam.)
ReplyDeleteAmy I have too many things to say about this wonderful post to write them all here; so I guess we'll need to have that BBC night!!! Bottom line though: you're the best, and so is your taste (especially in handsome men).
ReplyDelete